|
Salam Dr. Alam.
The phrase "Obey God and obey messenger" appears in the
Quran many times. Why do you not like this phrase? Why
do you suggest the unQuranic phrase "Obey God and obey
prophet"?
God and His messenger suggest the greeting "Salamun
Alaykum" or "Salam". Why do you not like this
greeting? Why do you prefer "ASARB" instead?
Please tell me how do you obey messenger by preferring "ASARB"
over"Salam"?
Please note that the Prophet is dead. I am sure you are
smart enough to understand the basic concept of Islam.
Thank you and may God guide me,
Muhammed Irtaza
[33:62] God's
Sunnah is unchangeable
[39:23] The Quran is the best Hadith
http://www.islamawakened.com/Quran/
C3.
On Sat,
4/2/11, Dr.Muhammad Mukhtar Alam <>
wrote:
Irtaza saheb,
ASARB is short for Assalam-o-alaikum wa rahmatullah wa
barkatuhu..Obedience to Allah and prophet of Allah both
and indeed Allah is our guide.
Muhammad Mukhtar Alam,Ph.D
C4. From:
Student of the Quran
To: Zina Khan <Subject: Re: Irtaza...did
your mulla in the slum teach you all this? / comment on
Dr. Alam
|
Salamun Alaykum, Dr. Alam.
What is ASARB? Why do you not like God's
teaching of greeting with "Salamun Alaykum"?
or "Salam"?
I never promote RK. The reason is simple,
like Muhammad, he cannot help me or guide
me. Only God guides me.
If you worship your idols beside God, it is
your choice. I will never ever disobey God
and do what you do in your worship.
May God guide me,
Muhammed Irtaza
C5.
--- On Sat,
4/2/11, Dr.Muhammad Mukhtar Alam
wrote:
Irtaza saheb,
ASARB, How many times do you remember Rashad
Khalafa? I hope you have not placed him
before following Allah SWT. Kindly note this
call for obedience to the Allah through
sending salam to our beloved Nabi SAW and
his posterity that we do in all salats while
reciting darood shareef.
Muhammad
Mukhtar Alam,Ph.D
Papers
and Presentations at
http://slideshare.net/mukhtaralam
Source: Discussion in
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/progressive-muslim/ group.
Bookmark and Share this Article:
|
|
|
|